More than half of Americans used buy-now-pay-later services in the past year. And 59% of those users were Gen Z.
BNPL feels like free money. Split that $200 purchase into four easy payments of $50. No interest. No credit check. No problem.
Except it is a problem. A big one.
The 20% Spending Trap
Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that customers spend 20% more when buy-now-pay-later is available. Not 2%. Not 5%. Twenty percent more.
That’s because BNPL removes friction. Friction is what makes you think twice before buying. When you hand over cash or see a credit card balance, your brain registers the cost. BNPL hides the cost behind small future payments. Your brain doesn’t register it the same way.
You’re not saving money with BNPL. You’re spending more money more easily.
Gen Z’s BNPL Reality
BNPL transaction volume hit $70 billion in 2025, growing 20% per year since 2021. 59% of users are Gen Z. Meanwhile, 40% of Gen Z credit cardholders carry a balance month to month, with average credit card debt of $3,493.
Here’s the irony: Gen Z actually prefers debit cards over credit cards. The top reasons? Avoiding debt and better spending visibility. Gen Z understands that credit cards are dangerous.
But BNPL bypasses that instinct. It feels like a debit card — small, manageable payments — but it functions like credit. You’re borrowing money to buy things you can’t afford right now.
The Hidden Costs
Late fees. Miss a payment and fees stack up fast. Some BNPL providers charge $7-$10 per missed payment.
Multiple overlapping payments. One BNPL purchase is manageable. But when you have 3, 4, 5 active BNPL plans running simultaneously, those “small” payments add up to hundreds per month.
Credit impact. More BNPL providers are reporting to credit bureaus now. Late payments can hurt your credit score.
Spending normalization. BNPL makes overspending feel normal. When every purchase can be split into payments, nothing feels too expensive. Until the total hits.
The Three-Question Test
Before using BNPL, ask yourself three questions:
1. Would I buy this with cash right now? If no, BNPL is hiding the fact that you can’t afford it.
2. Do I already have other BNPL payments running? If yes, you’re stacking debt whether you call it that or not.
3. Is this a need or a want? Use the 50/20/30 rule. If it’s a want and you’ve already spent your 20%, the answer is no.
What to Use Instead
Save first, buy later. If you want something that costs $200, save $50/week for a month. Same timeline as BNPL, but you own it free and clear.
Use a debit card. You already prefer them. Trust that instinct. If the money isn’t in your account, you can’t buy it.
Delete the apps. Afterpay, Klarna, Affirm — remove them from your phone. Out of sight, out of mind.
The Bottom Line
BNPL is designed to make you spend more. The data proves it: 20% more spending when it’s available. Gen Z is the primary target, and 59% of users are falling for it.
You’re smarter than that. Use cash. Use debit. Save first. And keep that 30% savings rate intact.
Build a real budget. Use our free tools